What are the possible causes of right upper quadrant flank pain under the ribs, both anteriorly and posteriorly, in a patient who has had a cholecystectomy?

Right Upper Quadrant and Flank Pain After Cholecystectomy

Primary Differential Diagnosis

In a patient without a gallbladder experiencing right upper quadrant pain extending to the flank (both anterior and posterior), the most likely causes are hepatic pathology, biliary duct disease (retained stones, stricture, or sphincter of Oddi dysfunction), renal/urologic conditions, or referred pain from colonic sources. 1, 2, 3

The pain location is critical here: true flank pain (lateral between ribs and pelvis) suggests renal or musculoskeletal causes rather than typical biliary pathology, which radiates to the upper back or right infrascapular region. 3 However, when pain involves both the RUQ anteriorly and posteriorly under the ribs, you must consider:

Post-Cholecystectomy Biliary Causes

• Retained common bile duct stones (choledocholithiasis) – occurs in 5-10% of post-cholecystectomy patients 2, 4
• Biliary stricture – from surgical injury or chronic inflammation 2
• Sphincter of Oddi dysfunction – functional obstruction causing recurrent biliary-type pain 2, 5, 6
• Cystic duct remnant syndrome – retained long cystic duct stump with stone formation 2

Hepatic Causes

• Chronic liver disease (cirrhosis, fatty liver, metabolic syndrome-associated steatosis) – can present as chronic RUQ discomfort 2
• Hepatic masses or infiltrative processes 2

Renal/Urologic Causes

• Nephrolithiasis or pyelonephritis – classic flank pain radiating anteriorly 3, 7
• Renal masses or hydronephrosis 7

Gastrointestinal Causes

• Hepatic flexure pathology (colonic distension, inflammation, mass) – can cause RUQ pain during bowel movements 1
• Peptic ulcer disease or gastroesophageal reflux – may mimic biliary pain 2
• Duodenal diverticulum (Lemmel syndrome) – rare cause of biliary obstruction 4

Other Considerations

• Musculoskeletal pain – rib pathology, intercostal neuralgia 3, 7
• Pulmonary causes – lower lobe pneumonia, pleurisy 7

---

Recommended Diagnostic Algorithm

Step 1: Initial Laboratory Evaluation

• Complete metabolic panel with liver function tests (AST, ALT, alkaline phosphatase, GGT, total/direct bilirubin) to assess for hepatobiliary pathology 1, 2
• Complete blood count to detect leukocytosis suggesting infection 2
• Urinalysis to evaluate for renal causes 7
• Lipase if pancreatic pathology is suspected 2

Step 2: First-Line Imaging – Right Upper Quadrant Ultrasound

The American College of Radiology rates RUQ ultrasound as 9/9 (usually appropriate) for RUQ pain evaluation and should be obtained immediately as the first-line imaging study. 1, 2

Ultrasound should specifically evaluate for:

• Biliary duct dilatation (common bile duct >6-7mm suggests obstruction) 2
• Choledocholithiasis (though sensitivity is limited at 22.5-75% for distal CBD stones) 2
• Hepatic parenchymal abnormalities (heterogeneous echotexture, masses, cirrhosis) 2
• Renal pathology (stones, hydronephrosis, masses) 7

Critical caveat: Ultrasound has limitations for visualizing the distal common bile duct due to overlying bowel gas, so a normal ultrasound does NOT exclude choledocholithiasis or sphincter of Oddi dysfunction. 2

Step 3: Advanced Imaging Based on Ultrasound Findings

If Ultrasound Shows Biliary Dilatation or Elevated LFTs:

MRCP is the preferred next imaging modality, with 85-100% sensitivity and 90% specificity for detecting choledocholithiasis and biliary obstruction. 2

• MRCP provides comprehensive evaluation of the entire biliary tree, including the cystic duct remnant, and detects stones, strictures, and the level/cause of obstruction with 91-100% accuracy 2
• Order "MRI abdomen with MRCP" – the MRCP sequences themselves (heavily T2-weighted) provide diagnostic information without IV contrast 2
• Add IV gadolinium contrast if you need to evaluate for complications (cholangitis, hepatic masses, inflammatory changes) 2

If Ultrasound is Normal but Pain Persists:

Consider hepatobiliary scintigraphy (HIDA scan) with cholecystokinin stimulation to evaluate for sphincter of Oddi dysfunction or functional biliary disorders. 2, 5, 6

• HIDA scan can detect delayed transit to small bowel after fatty meal stimulation, characteristic of sphincter of Oddi dyskinesia 5
• In one study, HIDA scan revealed a biliary cause in >70% of patients with RUQ pain and normal ultrasound 5
• This is particularly useful in post-cholecystectomy patients with biliary-type pain 6

If Renal Pathology is Suspected:

• Non-contrast CT abdomen/pelvis is the gold standard for detecting nephrolithiasis 7

If All Biliary Imaging is Negative:

Consider an empiric trial of a proton pump inhibitor (omeprazole 20-40 mg daily for 4-8 weeks) to address possible gastroesophageal reflux disease or peptic ulcer disease. 2

If this fails, proceed to upper endoscopy to directly evaluate for gastroduodenal pathology. 2

---

Critical Clinical Pitfalls to Avoid

Don't Skip Ultrasound and Go Directly to CT

• Ultrasound is more appropriate for initial evaluation, avoids unnecessary radiation, and is superior for detecting gallstones (CT sensitivity is only 39-75% because 80% of stones are non-calcified) 1, 2
• Reserve CT for critically ill patients with peritoneal signs or suspected complications (perforation, abscess, emphysematous cholecystitis) 2

Don't Dismiss Heterogeneous Liver on Ultrasound

• A heterogeneous liver appearance warrants further investigation with MRI abdomen with MRCP and IV gadolinium to evaluate for chronic liver disease, cirrhosis, or infiltrative processes 2
• Don't label it as a "normal variant" without proper workup 2

Don't Repeat Ultrasound or CT After Initial Negative Workup

• These modalities are inferior to MRCP for detecting subtle biliary abnormalities and add no diagnostic value 2
• If ultrasound and CT are negative, proceed directly to MRCP 2

Recognize That Pain Location Matters

• True lateral flank pain is more consistent with renal pathology than biliary disease 3
• Biliary pain typically radiates to the upper back or right infrascapular area, not the lateral flank 3
• Pain triggered by bowel movements suggests colonic or mechanical causes rather than primary hepatobiliary disease 1

Consider Sphincter of Oddi Dysfunction in Post-Cholecystectomy Patients

• This is a common cause of persistent biliary-type pain after cholecystectomy 6
• Type I SOD (with elevated LFTs and dilated CBD) benefits from empiric sphincterotomy 6
• Type II SOD (with only one objective finding) requires sphincter of Oddi manometry before sphincterotomy 6
• Type III SOD (pain only, no objective findings) may represent visceral hyperalgesia and should be treated conservatively with antidepressants or botulinum toxin injection before invasive therapy 6

Don't Perform ERCP as a Diagnostic Test

• ERCP carries significant risks (pancreatitis 3-5%, bleeding 2%, cholangitis 1%, mortality 0.4%) and should only be performed after non-invasive imaging confirms biliary obstruction requiring therapeutic intervention 2

---

When to Refer to Gastroenterology

• Elevated bilirubin or liver enzymes with biliary dilatation on imaging – urgent ERCP may be needed 2, 4
• Suspected sphincter of Oddi dysfunction – may require sphincter of Oddi manometry and therapeutic sphincterotomy 6
• Persistent pain despite negative imaging – consider endoscopic evaluation and possible therapeutic trials 2, 6
• Lemmel syndrome (periampullary duodenal diverticulum causing biliary obstruction) – may require surgical intervention if ERCP fails 4