What are the resting anal sphincter pressures before and after a low‑grade fistulotomy removing about 30 % of the internal anal sphincter, and how much pressure can be regained with pelvic‑floor (Kegel) training?

Anal Sphincter Pressures Before and After Low Fistulotomy and Recovery with Pelvic Floor Training

A low fistulotomy removing approximately 30% of the internal anal sphincter will reduce resting anal pressure from a baseline of roughly 85–90 mmHg to approximately 60 mmHg postoperatively, and while pelvic floor (Kegel) exercises can improve coordination and external sphincter function, they cannot restore the lost internal sphincter tone because the internal sphincter is smooth muscle under autonomic control, not voluntary control. 12

Baseline Resting Pressures Before Fistulotomy

• Normal healthy individuals have a mean resting anal pressure of approximately 73 ± 27 cm H₂O (≈54–73 mmHg), with the internal anal sphincter generating the majority of this basal tone. 34
• Patients with anal fistulas typically have baseline resting pressures of 85.9 ± 20.4 mmHg in the distal anal canal before any surgical intervention. 2
• The internal anal sphincter is responsible for 70–85% of resting tone, while the external sphincter contributes primarily to voluntary squeeze pressure. 5

Postoperative Pressure Changes After Low Fistulotomy

• Resting pressure drops significantly after fistulotomy involving the lower third of the sphincter complex, falling from approximately 85.9 mmHg to 60.2 mmHg (a reduction of roughly 30%). 2
• This pressure reduction is most pronounced in the distal 2–3 cm of the anal canal, where the internal sphincter was divided. 16
• The pressure drop is immediate and measurable at 1 month postoperatively, reflecting the permanent loss of smooth muscle tissue. 12

Gender-Specific Considerations

• Women have significantly lower baseline pressures than men both before and especially after fistulotomy, making them more vulnerable to postoperative incontinence. 1
• Anterior fistulotomy in women should be avoided entirely due to the shorter anterior sphincter length and smaller external sphincter volume. 75

Recovery and Pressure Regain Over Time

• Spontaneous partial recovery occurs without any intervention: resting pressure gradually increases from the 1-month nadir of 86 mmHg to approximately 110 mmHg at 12 months after lateral internal sphincterotomy (a similar procedure). 3
• This recovery represents adaptive changes in the remaining internal sphincter smooth muscle (hypertrophy and increased baseline tone), not regeneration of divided muscle. 3
• Even after 12 months of natural recovery, postoperative pressures remain significantly lower than preoperative baseline (110 mmHg vs. 138 mmHg in one study). 3

Role of Pelvic Floor (Kegel) Training

What Kegels Can Improve

• Voluntary squeeze pressure and external sphincter coordination can be enhanced through pelvic floor physical therapy with internal and external myofascial release, performed 2–3 times weekly. 8
• Kegel exercises improve external anal sphincter contraction strength, which contributes to continence during urgency and physical stress. 8
• Biofeedback therapy targeting rectal sensation and coordination of pelvic floor muscles can improve functional outcomes. 8

What Kegels Cannot Restore

• Resting anal tone is generated by the internal anal sphincter, which is smooth muscle under autonomic (involuntary) control and therefore not responsive to voluntary pelvic floor exercises. 54
• The internal sphincter cannot be "exercised" or strengthened through Kegel training because it lacks voluntary innervation. 5
• Divided internal sphincter muscle does not regenerate; the pressure recovery seen over 12 months represents compensatory hypertrophy of remaining tissue, not new muscle growth. 3

Quantitative Summary of Pressure Changes

Timepoint	Resting Pressure (mmHg)	Change from Baseline
Preoperative baseline	85–90	—
1 month post-fistulotomy	60	↓ 30%
12 months post-fistulotomy	70–75 (estimated)	↓ 15–20%

Note: These values are extrapolated from studies of intersphincteric fistulotomy and lateral internal sphincterotomy, which involve similar degrees of internal sphincter division. 132

Clinical Implications and Risk Factors for Incontinence

• Low preoperative voluntary contraction pressure (external sphincter weakness) is an independent risk factor for postoperative incontinence after fistulotomy. 2
• Patients with multiple previous drainage surgeries have significantly higher incontinence rates (20.3% overall incontinence rate in one series). 2
• Preoperative anal manometry is useful to identify high-risk patients (those with baseline squeeze pressure <100 mmHg) who may benefit from sphincter-preserving techniques instead of fistulotomy. 2

Critical Pitfalls to Avoid

• Do not promise patients that Kegel exercises will restore lost resting tone—this is physiologically impossible because the internal sphincter is smooth muscle. 54
• Avoid fistulotomy in women with anterior fistulas due to asymmetrical anatomy and high incontinence risk. 75
• Never use cutting setons, which cause forced sphincter migration and are associated with a 57% incontinence rate. 77
• Manual anal dilatation is absolutely contraindicated, carrying a 10–30% permanent incontinence risk. 54

Realistic Expectations for Pelvic Floor Therapy

• Pelvic floor physical therapy should be initiated 2–3 times weekly for 6–12 months to maximize external sphincter function and coordination. 8
• Expected improvements include better urgency control, reduced soiling, and improved squeeze pressure, but not restoration of baseline resting tone. 8
• Internal biofeedback therapy is necessary because external techniques alone cannot address internal sphincter dysfunction or rectal sensory feedback. 8