What is Lysine?
Lysine (L-lysine) is an essential amino acid that has been studied as a potential supplement for preventing recurrent herpes simplex virus (HSV) outbreaks, but the evidence for its efficacy is weak and inconsistent, making it a poor choice compared to proven antiviral medications for managing herpes labialis.
Mechanism and Rationale
Lysine is an essential amino acid that cannot be synthesized by the human body and must be obtained through diet or supplementation. 1 The theoretical basis for lysine supplementation in herpes infections stems from in vitro studies showing that:
- When the ratio of arginine to lysine favors arginine, viral replication is enhanced 1
- Conversely, when lysine predominates over arginine, viral replication may be suppressed 1
- The hypothesis suggests that lysine competes with arginine for viral protein synthesis, potentially inhibiting HSV replication 1
Evidence Quality and Clinical Efficacy
Studies Showing Potential Benefit
Some older studies suggested modest benefits:
- A 1978 multicenter study of 45 patients receiving 312-1,200 mg daily reported accelerated recovery and suppressed recurrence 1
- A 1984 crossover trial found that maintaining serum lysine concentrations above 165 nmol/ml correlated with decreased recurrence rates when patients received 1,000 mg daily 2
Studies Showing No Benefit
However, other controlled trials found no effect:
- A 1984 double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of 400 mg three times daily (1,200 mg total) in 21 patients with frequent recurrences found no substantial benefit for either treatment of active episodes or prophylaxis 3
- The study concluded that lysine is unlikely to improve frequently recurrent herpes simplex infections in the majority of patients 3
Systematic Review Findings
A 2017 systematic review concluded that lysine supplementation appears ineffective for prophylaxis or treatment at doses less than 1 g/day without concurrent low-arginine diets 4. The review noted:
- Doses exceeding 3 g/day may improve patients' subjective experience, but evidence remains limited 4
- Longer duration controlled studies of daily doses exceeding 1.2 g/day are needed to definitively test its role 4
Dietary Considerations
The typical American diet already provides significantly more lysine than arginine, with mean daily intakes of 8.11 g lysine versus 6.32 g arginine 5. This is because:
- High-lysine foods (meat, dairy products) are consumed more frequently than high-arginine foods (legumes, whole grains, nuts) 5
- There is large variability in individual amino acid intake, which may explain conflicting study results 5
Safety Considerations
Patients with cardiovascular or gallbladder disease should be cautioned about theoretical risks of lysine supplementation 4. The evidence does not establish clear safety parameters for long-term high-dose use.
Comparison to Proven Antiviral Therapy
In contrast to the weak and inconsistent evidence for lysine, proven oral antiviral medications for herpes labialis include:
- Valacyclovir 2 g twice daily for 1 day reduces median episode duration by 1.0 day compared to placebo 6
- Famciclovir 1500 mg single dose significantly reduces healing time of primary lesions 6
- For patients with six or more recurrences per year, daily suppressive therapy with valacyclovir 500 mg once daily reduces recurrence frequency by ≥75% 6
Clinical Bottom Line for Healthy Adults with Occasional Herpes Labialis
For a healthy adult with occasional recurrent cold sores, lysine supplementation is not recommended as a primary or adjunctive therapy because:
- Evidence is inconsistent and of poor quality, with negative controlled trials 3
- Most Americans already consume adequate lysine through diet 5
- Proven antiviral medications (valacyclovir, famciclovir, acyclovir) are far more effective 6
- Early initiation of oral antivirals during the prodromal phase or within 24 hours of lesion onset is the most effective strategy 6
If a patient insists on trying lysine despite counseling about limited evidence, doses of at least 1-3 g daily would be required based on available studies, but this should not replace or delay proven antiviral therapy 4.