Lysine Supplementation for Recurrent Oral Herpes
Direct Recommendation
Lysine supplementation is not recommended as first-line therapy for recurrent oral herpes (cold sores) in healthy adults; instead, use CDC-recommended oral antiviral therapy (valacyclovir, famciclovir, or acyclovir) for episodic treatment or suppressive therapy if experiencing ≥6 recurrences per year. 1
Evidence-Based Treatment Algorithm
First-Line Management: Oral Antivirals
For occasional recurrent cold sores:
- Episodic therapy: Valacyclovir 2g twice daily for 1 day (12 hours apart), initiated during prodrome or within 24 hours of lesion onset 1, 2
- Alternative regimens: Famciclovir 1500mg single dose, or acyclovir 400mg five times daily for 5 days 1, 2
- Critical timing: Treatment must begin within 24 hours of symptom onset, as peak viral replication occurs in the first 24 hours; delayed treatment markedly reduces efficacy 1, 2
For frequent recurrences (≥6 episodes per year):
- Suppressive therapy: Valacyclovir 500mg once daily, acyclovir 400mg twice daily, or famciclovir 250mg twice daily 1, 2
- Efficacy: Reduces recurrence frequency by ≥75% 1, 2
- Duration: Safe for continuous use up to 6 years with acyclovir; reassess after 1 year to determine if ongoing suppression is needed 1, 2
Lysine: Evidence Summary and Clinical Role
Why Lysine Is Not Recommended
The evidence for lysine supplementation is weak, contradictory, and methodologically limited:
Negative controlled trial:
- A double-blind, placebo-controlled study of lysine 400mg three times daily (1200mg/day total) in 21 patients found no substantial benefit for treatment or prevention of recurrent herpes simplex 3
Positive but low-quality evidence:
- One 1984 trial (26 patients) suggested benefit when serum lysine exceeded 165 nmol/mL with 1000mg daily supplementation 4
- A 1978 uncontrolled study (45 patients, 312-1200mg daily) reported subjective improvement 5
- A 1983 survey (1543 subjects, average 936mg daily) showed 84% self-reported benefit, but this was an uncontrolled questionnaire study with high risk of bias 6
2017 systematic review conclusion:
- Lysine appears ineffective at doses <1g/day without low-arginine diets 7
- Doses >3g/day may improve subjective symptoms, but longer controlled trials are needed 7
- The review explicitly states current evidence is insufficient to recommend lysine for prophylaxis 7
If a Patient Insists on Trying Lysine
Dosing regimen (based on limited evidence):
- Prophylactic dose: 1000-3000mg daily in divided doses 7, 4
- Duration: At least 6-12 months to assess efficacy 4
- Adjunctive measure: Consider low-arginine diet (avoid nuts, chocolate, seeds) 7
Safety considerations:
- Renal impairment: Lysine is renally excreted; use caution and consider dose reduction in patients with impaired kidney function 7
- Cardiovascular disease: Theoretical risk of increased cholesterol and atherosclerosis; warn patients with cardiovascular disease 7
- Gallbladder disease: Theoretical risk; caution advised 7
- Common side effects: Generally well-tolerated; gastrointestinal upset may occur at higher doses 7
Monitoring:
- No specific laboratory monitoring is required for lysine supplementation 7, 4
- One study suggested serum lysine levels >165 nmol/mL correlate with reduced recurrence, but routine serum monitoring is not practical in clinical practice 4
When to Use Antiviral Therapy Instead of Lysine
Always use antiviral therapy as first-line in these scenarios:
Frequent recurrences (≥6 per year): Daily suppressive antiviral therapy reduces recurrence by ≥75%, far exceeding any potential lysine benefit 1, 2
Severe or prolonged episodes: Oral antivirals shorten healing time by approximately 1 day when started early, with high-quality evidence 1, 2
Immunocompromised patients: Higher doses or IV acyclovir may be required; lysine has no established role in this population 1, 2
Complicated disease: Extensive oral involvement, gingivostomatitis, or disseminated infection requires systemic antiviral therapy (oral or IV acyclovir 5-10mg/kg every 8 hours) 2
Patient preference for evidence-based therapy: Antivirals have robust, guideline-level evidence; lysine does not 1, 2
Safety Considerations for Antiviral Therapy
Renal function assessment:
- Elderly patients (≥80 years): Assess creatinine clearance before initiating valacyclovir, acyclovir, or famciclovir to allow dose adjustment and prevent neurotoxicity 2
- Renal impairment: Dose adjustments mandatory for all oral antivirals based on creatinine clearance 1, 2
Antiviral resistance:
- Immunocompetent patients: Resistance remains extremely rare (<0.5%) even with prolonged episodic use 1, 2
- Immunocompromised patients: Resistance occurs in ~7% of cases; if suspected (lesions not improving after 7-10 days), obtain viral culture and consider IV foscarnet 40mg/kg every 8 hours 1, 2
Common side effects:
- Headache (<10%), nausea (<4%), diarrhea—typically mild to moderate 2
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Relying on topical antivirals: Topical acyclovir is substantially less effective than systemic therapy and should not be used 1, 2
Delaying treatment beyond 24 hours: Efficacy decreases markedly when treatment is not started during prodrome or within the first day of lesions 1, 2
Using lysine as monotherapy for frequent recurrences: Patients with ≥6 episodes per year should receive daily suppressive antiviral therapy, which has proven efficacy 1, 2
Failing to counsel on transmission risk: Patients remain contagious until all lesions are fully crusted; asymptomatic shedding can occur even on suppressive therapy, though at reduced frequency 1, 2
Not addressing triggers: UV light exposure, fever, stress, and menstruation can trigger recurrences; advise sunscreen (SPF ≥15) or zinc oxide for UV protection 1, 2
Practical Clinical Approach
For a healthy adult with occasional cold sores:
- Prescribe valacyclovir 2g twice daily for 1 day (or famciclovir 1500mg single dose) to keep on hand 1, 2
- Instruct patient to initiate at first sign of prodrome (tingling, burning) 1, 2
- Counsel on trigger avoidance (sunscreen, stress management) 1, 2
- If patient requests lysine, explain the weak evidence and recommend antiviral therapy first; if they still wish to try lysine, suggest 1000-3000mg daily with caution regarding cardiovascular/gallbladder disease 7
For a patient with ≥6 recurrences per year: