HPV Vaccination in HPV-Positive Women
Yes, women who are already HPV-positive should receive the HPV vaccine because it provides protection against the other HPV vaccine types they have not yet acquired, even though it will not treat their existing infection. 1
Key Principle: Protection Against Remaining HPV Types
The fundamental rationale for vaccinating HPV-positive women is straightforward:
- Women infected with one or more HPV vaccine types before vaccination remain protected against disease caused by the other vaccine HPV types for which they are naive. 1
- The quadrivalent vaccine was 100% effective (95% CI, 79%-100%) in preventing cervical intraepithelial neoplasia 2 or 3 or adenocarcinoma in situ caused by HPV types for which women were negative at enrollment, even when they were already infected with other vaccine types. 2
- Efficacy for preventing vulvar or vaginal HPV-related lesions was 94% (95% CI, 81%-99%) in women already infected with some vaccine types. 2
Clinical Scenarios Where Vaccination is Recommended
Women with Abnormal Pap Tests or Known HPV Infection
- Females with equivocal or abnormal Pap tests are unlikely to be infected with all four HPV vaccine types and might not be infected with any vaccine type at all. 1
- Vaccination provides protection against HPV vaccine types not already acquired, though benefit decreases with increasing severity of Pap findings due to higher likelihood of HPV 16 or 18 infection. 1
- Women must be counseled that the vaccine has no therapeutic effect on existing HPV infection or cervical lesions. 1
Women with Positive High-Risk HPV Tests
- Women with a positive HC2 High-Risk test could have infection with any of 13 high-risk types, but this assay does not identify specific HPV types. 1
- These women might not have been infected with any of the four HPV vaccine types, making vaccination beneficial for protection against vaccine types not yet acquired. 1
Women with History of Genital Warts
- A history of genital warts indicates infection with HPV, most often type 6 or 11, but these females might not have infection with both HPV 6 and 11 or with HPV 16 or 18. 1
- Vaccination provides protection against HPV vaccine types not already acquired, though it will not treat existing genital warts. 1
Important Counseling Points
No Therapeutic Effect
- Clinical trial results clearly demonstrate the vaccine will have no therapeutic effect on existing HPV infection or cervical lesions. 1
- The vaccine is purely preventive for HPV types not yet encountered. 1
No Pre-Vaccination Testing Required
- Neither Pap testing nor HPV DNA/antibody testing is required before vaccination. 3
- The ACIP recommendations support vaccination of the general population without prescreening. 2
- This approach is both practical and evidence-based, as most women are unlikely to be infected with all vaccine types. 1
Continued Screening Necessity
- Cervical cancer screening recommendations have not changed for females who receive HPV vaccine. 1
- HPV vaccine types are responsible for approximately 70% of cervical cancers, meaning vaccinated women remain at risk from non-vaccine HPV types. 1
- Vaccinated individuals still need age-appropriate Pap smears regardless of vaccination status. 3
Age Considerations
- The vaccine is licensed for females aged 9-26 years, with routine vaccination recommended at ages 11-12 years and catch-up vaccination through age 26. 1, 3
- Vaccine efficacy was 90.5% (95% CI 73.7-97.5) for vaccine-specific HPV infections and lesions in women aged 24-45 years who are HPV DNA-negative at vaccination. 4
- While efficacy is lower in adult women compared to adolescents, older women remain at risk of new HPV infections and persistent high-risk HPV infection. 4, 5
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Do not withhold vaccination based on abnormal Pap results, known HPV infection, or history of genital warts. 1, 3
- Do not assume that sexually active women or those with previous HPV exposure cannot benefit from vaccination. 3, 2
- Do not delay vaccination to perform HPV testing—this is unnecessary and delays protection. 3, 2
- Remember that even women infected with vaccine-type HPV benefit from protection against the remaining vaccine types. 1, 2