What are the next steps in managing a patient with persistent shoulder pain despite a normal plain radiograph?

Next Steps for Shoulder Pain with Negative X-ray

When shoulder radiographs are normal but pain persists, proceed directly to MRI without contrast as the next imaging study, as soft-tissue injuries—particularly rotator cuff and labral tears—are the most common causes of post-traumatic shoulder pain with normal radiographs. 1

Immediate Clinical Assessment

Before ordering advanced imaging, clarify several key clinical features that will guide your diagnostic pathway:

• Determine if the pain is traumatic or atraumatic, as this fundamentally changes your differential diagnosis and imaging approach 2
• Document the exact mechanism of injury if trauma occurred—including fall height, landing position, and whether overhead activities or specific movements triggered symptoms 2
• Classify symptom duration as acute (<2 weeks) versus chronic (>6 months), which influences both imaging selection and management strategies 2
• Age-stratify your approach: In patients under 35-40 years, prioritize assessment for instability and labral pathology; in those over 35-40 years, focus on rotator cuff disease and degenerative changes 2

Advanced Imaging Selection Algorithm

For Acute Traumatic Shoulder Pain (Non-localized)

MRI without contrast is the preferred next study when radiographs are normal, because acute intra-articular pathology typically produces significant joint effusion that outlines soft-tissue structures without requiring contrast injection 1

• MRI excels at detecting rotator cuff tears, labral injuries, bone marrow contusion, capsular tears, and ligament injuries 1
• MRI is superior to MR arthrography in the acute trauma setting because the natural joint effusion from acute injury provides adequate contrast 1

For Chronic or Atraumatic Shoulder Pain

The imaging choice depends on your clinical suspicion:

• If rotator cuff pathology is suspected (pain with overhead activities, positive impingement signs, age >35 years): Either MRI or ultrasound is appropriate 1, 2

  • Both modalities have similarly high sensitivity and specificity for full-thickness rotator cuff tears 1
  • Ultrasound is equivalent to MRI for rotator cuff evaluation when performed by experienced operators and offers cost-effectiveness plus dynamic assessment 2, 3
  • MRI has somewhat lower sensitivity than MR arthrography for partial-thickness tears but remains excellent for full-thickness tears 1

• If labral pathology or instability is suspected (age <35-40 years, history of dislocation/subluxation, clicking with shoulder movement): MR arthrography is the gold standard 4

  • MR arthrography is superior to noncontrast MRI for detecting labroligamentous injuries and partial-thickness rotator cuff tears 1, 4
  • In chronic cases without acute effusion, MR arthrography is strongly preferred over noncontrast MRI 4

Alternative Imaging Modalities

• Ultrasound can be used as the primary imaging modality if local expertise is available, particularly for rotator cuff and biceps tendon pathology 2, 3

  • Sensitivity 85%, specificity 90% for rotator cuff tears 2
  • Allows real-time dynamic assessment during arm movement 2, 5
  • Cannot adequately assess labral pathology or instability 1

• CT arthrography may be considered only if MRI is contraindicated, though it is inferior to MR arthrography for partial-thickness rotator cuff tears 1

• Bone scan and FDG-PET are rarely indicated and have poor specificity for shoulder pain evaluation 1

Common Diagnostic Pitfalls to Avoid

• Do not assume absence of trauma means absence of significant pathology—elderly patients can sustain osteoporotic fractures with minimal or unrecognized trauma 2
• Do not order noncontrast MRI as initial advanced imaging for chronic labral pathology—MR arthrography provides superior visualization when there is no acute effusion 4
• Do not rely on radiographs alone to exclude dislocation—standard AP views miss up to 50% of glenohumeral dislocations; axillary or scapular Y views are essential 6
• Do not skip imaging in patients with persistent pain—while 80% of subacromial impingement resolves with conservative therapy, imaging becomes appropriate if symptoms persist beyond 3-6 months of adequate physical therapy 2

Initial Conservative Management While Awaiting Imaging

Regardless of imaging plans, initiate conservative treatment immediately:

• Complete rest from aggravating activities until pain-free 2, 7
• NSAIDs for acute pain management if no contraindications 6, 7
• Physical therapy referral focusing on range-of-motion restoration, particularly external rotation and abduction, followed by progressive rotator cuff and scapular stabilizer strengthening once pain-free motion is achieved 2, 7
• Avoid overhead pulley exercises as they encourage uncontrolled abduction and can worsen rotator cuff pathology 2, 6
• Consider subacromial corticosteroid injection for more severe cases, which has demonstrated significant pain reduction effects 2, 6

When to Refer to Orthopedics

• Defer orthopedic referral until after 3-6 months of adequate conservative therapy for suspected impingement or rotator cuff tendinopathy, as approximately 80% of patients recover with physical therapy alone 2
• Immediate orthopedic consultation is warranted if imaging reveals unstable or significantly displaced fractures, complete rotator cuff tears in young active patients, or if there are neurological deficits suggesting nerve involvement 6