Hip Fracture Mortality Rates and Interventions
Mortality Rates in Older Adults with Hip Fractures
Hip fractures in patients over 65 carry a devastating mortality burden: 8.4% die within 30 days, 15-30% die within one year, and mortality remains three times higher than the general geriatric population throughout the first year. 1, 2
Short-Term Mortality (30 days)
- 30-day mortality is 8.4%, with up to 50% of these deaths potentially preventable through optimized acute management 1, 2
- Surgical delays beyond even 12 hours significantly increase the adjusted risk of 30-day mortality 1, 2
One-Year Mortality
- Overall 1-year mortality ranges from 15-30% 3, 1, 2
- The highest mortality risk is concentrated in the immediate post-fracture period, gradually decreasing but remaining elevated throughout the entire first year 1
- Geriatric hip fracture mortality in the first year is three times higher than expected in the general geriatric population 3, 1
Long-Term Mortality Beyond One Year
- Patients face a 3- to 4-fold increased risk of mortality in the 5 years following hip fracture 1
- The increased relative risk for mortality remains elevated for months and perhaps even years following hip fracture 1
High-Risk Patient Populations
Male Gender
- Men have substantially worse outcomes than women, with 37.5-38% mortality at 1 year compared to 24-28% in women 1
- Male sex carries a hazard ratio of 1.91 for mortality, attributed to excess comorbidity burden and higher infection rates 1, 4
Advanced Age
- Mortality is highest (19%) in patients ≥86 years old 1, 2
- At 80 years old, patients fall into the high-risk category with significantly elevated mortality 1
Dementia and Cognitive Impairment
- Dementia increases mortality risk with a hazard ratio of 2.72 4
- Patients with dementia have 1.45 times higher odds of overall postoperative complications, including surgical site infection (OR 1.58), urinary tract infection (OR 1.87), and respiratory complications (OR 1.49) 5
- Cognitive impairment carries a hazard ratio of 2.06 for mortality 4
- Delirium increases mortality risk with a hazard ratio of 2.14 4
Cardiovascular Disease
- Cardiovascular disease doubles the risk of mortality (HR 2.10) 4, 6
- History of cardiovascular disease increases postoperative complications with an odds ratio of 1.33 5
Chronic Lung Disease
- Respiratory disease shows a trend toward increased mortality (HR 1.49), though this did not reach statistical significance in meta-analysis 4
- Respiratory complications are significantly more common in hip fracture patients and contribute to mortality 5
Renal Impairment
- Renal disease increases mortality risk with a hazard ratio of 1.66 4
- Chronic renal failure increases postoperative complications with an odds ratio of 1.36 5
Frailty and Sarcopenia
- Sarcopenia is the strongest predictor of out-of-hospital mortality, with a hazard ratio of 4.77 1, 2
- Greater comorbidity burden and frailty independently increase death risk 1
- Patients with more than two comorbidities have significantly higher mortality 7
- ASA score of III-IV is an independent risk factor for one-year mortality 7
Nutritional Status
- Blood albumin level <3.5 g/dL on admission is significantly associated with mortality 7
- Total lymphocyte count <1500 cells/mL on admission is an independent risk factor for one-year mortality 7
- Low hemoglobin levels on admission independently predict one-year mortality 7
Evidence-Based Interventions to Reduce Mortality
1. Early Surgical Intervention (HIGHEST PRIORITY)
Surgery must be performed within 24-48 hours of hospital admission to significantly reduce both short-term and mid-term mortality rates. 3, 1, 2
- The 2022 AAOS guideline changed the recommendation from within 48 hours to within 24-48 hours based on improved outcomes data from high-volume centers 3
- Delays beyond 48 hours increase mortality, with the effect becoming more pronounced as delay extends 1
- Delays beyond even 12 hours significantly increase the adjusted risk of 30-day mortality 1, 2
- Critical pitfall to avoid: Do not delay surgery for minor medical optimization, as there is no evidence that delaying surgery to allow pre-operative physiological stabilization improves outcomes 1
- The ideal time to surgery is as soon as safely possible at a given facility with a given surgical team 3
2. Orthogeriatric Comanagement (SECOND PRIORITY)
To improve functional outcome and reduce length of hospital stay and mortality, orthogeriatric comanagement should be provided, especially in elderly patients with hip fracture. 3
- The joint care model between geriatrician and orthopedic surgeon on a dedicated orthogeriatric ward has been shown to have the shortest time to surgery, shortest length of inpatient stay, and lowest inpatient and 1-year mortality rate 3, 1
- Elderly fracture patients benefit from multidisciplinary comanagement, including a comprehensive geriatric assessment 3
- This is a Level IA recommendation with Grade A strength 3
3. Appropriate Preoperative Management
Fragility fractures should be managed in the context of a multidisciplinary clinical system, guaranteeing adequate preoperative assessment and preparation, including adequate pain relief, appropriate fluid management, and surgery within 48 hours of injury. 3
- Appropriate pain management should be provided before starting diagnostic investigations 1
- Adequate fluid management is essential in the preoperative period 3
- This is a Level IIA recommendation with Grade B strength 3
4. Prevention of Postoperative Complications
Particular attention must be paid to preventing surgical site infection, urinary tract infection, and respiratory complications, especially in patients with preoperative dementia. 5
- Any complication is an independent predictor of overall mortality with an odds ratio of 2.3 2
- Patients with dementia have significantly higher rates of surgical site infection (OR 1.58), urinary tract infection (OR 1.87), and respiratory complications (OR 1.49) 5
- The prevention or early diagnosis and treatment of serious infections remains an important challenge 6
5. Early Palliative Care for High-Risk Patients
- Early palliative care intervention (24-72 hours) for high-risk patients may reduce mortality 2
- This should be considered for patients with multiple risk factors including advanced age (≥86 years), male gender, dementia, sarcopenia, and multiple comorbidities 1, 2
6. Appropriate Rehabilitation Programme
An appropriate rehabilitation programme should consist of both early postfracture introduction of physical training and muscle strengthening and the long-term continuation of balance training and multidimensional fall prevention. 3
- This is a Level IIA recommendation with Grade B strength 3
- Early mobilization after surgery reduces mortality rates and minor/major medical complications due to immobility (e.g., decubitus ulcer, pneumonia, increased length of hospital stay) 3
Critical Pitfalls to Avoid
Do Not Delay Surgery for Medical Optimization
- There is no evidence that delaying surgery to allow pre-operative physiological stabilization improves outcomes 1
- Delay to the operating theater to enable optimization of acute medical problems must be weighed against the effects of prolonging pain and immobility 3
- Even delays beyond 12 hours significantly increase mortality risk 1, 2
Recognize Preventable Deaths
- Up to 50% of postoperative deaths may be potentially preventable through optimized acute management 1, 2
- Focus on preventing serious infections (septicemia, pneumonia, urinary tract infections) which carry relative odds of dying of 12.3,4.9, and increased risk respectively 6
Address Pain Immediately
- Appropriate pain management should be provided before starting diagnostic investigations 1
- Inadequate pain control prolongs immobility and increases complications 3