Radioactive Thyroid Scan with Mixed Increased and Suppressed Uptake
A radioactive thyroid scan showing both areas of increased uptake and suppressed uptake is pathognomonic for toxic multinodular goiter, where autonomous hyperfunctioning nodules ("hot" nodules) suppress the surrounding normal thyroid tissue. 1
Pattern Recognition and Diagnosis
The characteristic pattern you describe represents:
- Multiple "hot" areas (increased uptake) corresponding to autonomous hyperfunctioning nodules that are producing excess thyroid hormone independently of TSH control 1, 2
- Intervening "cold" areas (suppressed uptake) representing normal thyroid tissue that has been suppressed by the autonomous nodules through negative feedback on TSH 1, 3
This heterogeneous pattern with multiple areas of variable activity distributed throughout the gland is diagnostic of toxic multinodular goiter when TSH is suppressed 3, 2. The autonomous nodules function independently due to somatic activating gain-of-function mutations in the TSH receptor 2.
Differential Diagnosis Considerations
While toxic multinodular goiter is the most common cause of this pattern, other rare scenarios can produce mixed uptake:
- Marine-Lenhart syndrome: Coexistence of Graves' disease with an autonomously functioning nodule, showing diffuse uptake throughout the gland with superimposed focal increased uptake in the autonomous nodule 4
- Non-toxic multinodular goiter (euthyroid state): Shows heterogeneous uptake with variable activity but without suppression of intervening tissue, as TSH is not suppressed 3
The key distinguishing feature is the biochemical context: toxic multinodular goiter presents with suppressed TSH, elevated free T4/T3, and negative TSH receptor antibodies (ruling out Graves' disease) 1, 2.
Clinical Implications for Management
Definitive treatment planning should prioritize thyroidectomy as the preferred approach in younger patients or those with compressive symptoms, as it provides immediate cure and rapid restoration of normal thyroid function. 1
Alternative treatment options include:
- Radioactive iodine therapy: The scan pattern helps calculate the appropriate dose based on the volume of hyperfunctioning tissue; the goal is to achieve euthyroid status (not hypothyroidism as in Graves' disease) 3, 2
- Antithyroid medications: Typically used as a bridge to definitive therapy rather than long-term management 2
Important Caveats
- The scan has low positive predictive value for malignancy and cannot determine which nodules require biopsy 3. Any suspicious nodules on ultrasound should still undergo fine-needle aspiration regardless of their uptake pattern 3.
- Coexisting thyroid cancer can be missed if ultrasound evaluation is skipped and only scintigraphy is performed 3. Always perform ultrasound first in the diagnostic algorithm, even when TSH is suppressed 3.
- The pattern can evolve with treatment: autonomous nodules may change from "hot" to "cool" during antithyroid drug therapy as TSH levels normalize 4.