Does Progestin Increase Cervical Cancer Risk?
Progestin-only contraception does not appear to increase cervical cancer risk, while combined estrogen-progestin contraceptives modestly increase risk only with prolonged use (≥5 years) in women with persistent HPV infection. 1, 2
Key Distinction: Progestin-Only vs. Combined Contraceptives
The critical factor is whether the contraceptive contains estrogen in addition to progestin:
Progestin-Only Contraception
- Current or recent users of progestin-only contraception show NO increased cervical cancer risk (RR 0.91,95% CI 0.78-1.07) in the most recent large cohort study of over 20 million person-years. 2
- This finding is particularly important because it demonstrates that progestin alone does not drive cervical carcinogenesis. 2
- The systematic review examining studies that controlled for HPV infection found insufficient evidence to conclude that progestin-only methods increase risk. 3
Combined Estrogen-Progestin Contraceptives
- Current or recent users of combined contraceptives have a modestly increased risk (RR 1.40,95% CI 1.28-1.53) compared to never users. 2
- The risk increases with duration of use: no increased risk for <5 years of use (OR 0.73), but OR 2.82 for 5-9 years and OR 4.03 for ≥10 years of use in HPV-positive women. 4
- This translates to approximately 1 extra cervical cancer per 14,700 women using combined contraceptives for 1 year. 2
- The risk applies to both adenocarcinoma (RR 1.29) and squamous cell carcinoma (RR 1.31). 2
Clinical Context: HPV as the Primary Driver
Persistent HPV infection is the essential causative factor for cervical cancer, not hormonal contraception. 5
- HPV types 16 and 18 account for approximately 70% of cervical cancers. 5
- Combined contraceptives appear to act as a cofactor that increases risk up to four-fold only in women already positive for cervical HPV DNA. 4
- The mechanism may involve hormonal promotion of HPV-DNA integration into the host genome and modulation of cell apoptosis. 6
Risk Patterns and Reversibility
The increased risk with combined contraceptives shows important temporal patterns:
- Risk declines after discontinuation and returns to baseline after >10 years since last use. 6, 4
- The risk pattern increases with longer duration of use and declines after stopping, possibly taking longer to disappear among prolonged users. 2
- Ten-year combined oral contraceptive use from age 20 increases cumulative incidence of invasive cervical cancer at age 50 by approximately 1 case per 1,000 women. 6
FDA Drug Label Perspective
The FDA label for medroxyprogesterone acetate (a progestin-only injectable) states that long-term surveillance found no overall increased risk of cervical cancer and notes only a statistically insignificant increase in invasive squamous-cell cervical cancer in women first exposed before age 35 (RR 1.22-1.28,95% CI 0.93-1.70). 7
Guideline Recommendations
The CDC indicates that long-term use (≥5 years) of combined hormonal contraceptives may increase cervical carcinoma risk among women with persistent HPV infection. 1
However, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists recommends that women with cervical intraepithelial neoplasia can use hormonal contraceptives (Category 2, benefits generally outweigh risks). 1
Critical Prevention Strategies
Given the modest risk with combined contraceptives and no risk with progestin-only methods:
- Systematic cervical cancer screening remains the cornerstone of prevention, as screening and treatment of precancerous lesions lead to reductions in cervical cancer incidence, morbidity, and mortality. 5
- HPV vaccination is essential, particularly for users of combined contraceptives who were not vaccinated. 5, 2
- Long-term users of combined oral contraceptives should receive extra effort to include them in cervical screening programs. 4
Important Caveats
- Most studies do not adequately differentiate between combined oral contraceptives and progestin-only pills by recency or duration of use, which clouds interpretation. 3
- The absolute increase in cervical cancer risk from combined contraceptives is very small compared to the substantial protective effects against ovarian (40-60% reduction) and endometrial cancer (50% reduction). 1
- Injectable progestin-only contraception (DMPA) showed increased CIN3 incidence in one study (aOR 1.6), but this finding requires confirmation. 3