How should I evaluate and manage a chronically underweight adult female with normal thyroid function, normal glucose, negative eating‑disorder screening, who eats until satiety and prioritizes protein yet continues to lose weight?

Evaluation and Management of Chronic Constitutional Thinness

This patient most likely has constitutional thinness—a benign condition characterized by lifelong low BMI with normal metabolic function—and requires exclusion of occult malabsorption, hyperthyroidism despite normal screening tests, and malignancy before reassurance and supportive nutrition counseling.

Initial Diagnostic Workup

Laboratory Assessment Beyond Basic Thyroid Screening

• Obtain a complete blood count and comprehensive metabolic panel including electrolytes, liver enzymes, and renal function tests to identify occult systemic illness 1
• Measure free T3 in addition to TSH and free T4, as some patients with hyperthyroidism may have isolated T3 toxicosis not detected by standard thyroid screening 2
• Check celiac disease serologies (tissue transglutaminase IgA with total IgA), as celiac disease can present with chronic underweight without overt gastrointestinal symptoms and is associated with other autoimmune conditions 3
• Assess for micronutrient deficiencies including iron studies, vitamin B12, folate, and 25-hydroxyvitamin D, as chronic underweight can be associated with multiple nutritional deficiencies despite adequate caloric intake 3
• Consider inflammatory markers (ESR, CRP) to screen for occult inflammatory conditions such as inflammatory bowel disease that may cause weight loss 1

Physical Examination Priorities

• Document vital signs including orthostatic pulse and blood pressure changes, as these indicate hemodynamic compromise from malnutrition 1
• Assess for signs of malabsorption including muscle wasting pattern, skin changes, and evidence of fat-soluble vitamin deficiencies 1
• Examine for lymphadenopathy, hepatosplenomegaly, and abdominal masses to exclude occult malignancy as a cause of weight loss 1
• Evaluate for parotid gland enlargement and dental enamel erosion on lingual surfaces of maxillary anterior teeth, as these findings suggest covert purging behavior despite negative eating disorder screening 4

Reassessing for Occult Eating Disorder

When Standard Screening May Miss the Diagnosis

• Re-screen using the EAT-26 if not already completed, as validated screening tools are more sensitive than clinical interview alone for detecting eating disorders 5
• Specifically inquire about exercise patterns and duration, as excessive exercise can be a compensatory behavior that maintains low weight even with adequate food intake 1, 4
• Ask about laxative, diuretic, or diet pill use, as these compensatory behaviors may not be volunteered without direct questioning 1, 4
• Evaluate preoccupation with food, weight, and body shape as a percentage of daily thoughts, as cognitive preoccupation is a core feature of eating disorders that may persist despite normal eating behavior 4

Critical Pitfall to Avoid

• Do not accept patient self-report of "eating until full" as definitive evidence against restrictive eating disorder, as patients with anorexia nervosa often have altered satiety cues and genuinely feel full after consuming inadequate calories 1, 2

Management After Negative Workup

If All Testing is Normal

• Diagnose constitutional thinness when lifelong low BMI is present with normal metabolic parameters, normal eating behavior, and absence of medical or psychiatric pathology 2
• Provide reassurance that constitutional thinness is a benign variant and does not require treatment if the patient is asymptomatic and metabolically healthy 2
• Refer to a registered dietitian for nutrition optimization focusing on nutrient-dense foods to prevent micronutrient deficiencies, even if weight gain is not achievable 1
• Monitor weight stability rather than absolute weight, as progressive weight loss—even in a constitutionally thin person—warrants further investigation 1

Ongoing Monitoring Strategy

• Schedule follow-up visits every 3-6 months initially to document weight stability and reassess for new symptoms 1
• Repeat comprehensive metabolic panel and CBC annually to monitor for development of occult disease 1
• Maintain low threshold for additional workup if weight loss occurs, as new weight loss in a previously stable patient suggests acquired pathology 1

When to Pursue Advanced Testing

Red Flags Requiring Further Investigation

• Any documented weight loss from baseline warrants gastrointestinal evaluation including upper endoscopy and colonoscopy to exclude inflammatory bowel disease or celiac disease 1
• Persistent fatigue, diarrhea, or abdominal pain should prompt comprehensive gastrointestinal workup including fecal calprotectin and consideration of endoscopy 1
• Abnormal laboratory values on initial screening require targeted evaluation based on the specific abnormality (e.g., anemia workup, liver disease evaluation) 1